Heat Pump vs. Air Conditioning: Performance Comparison Guide

Everyone is grappling with climbing energy costs as they search for energy-efficient heating and cooling options. Homeowners want to be comfortable in their houses without paying a fortune. For homeowners in need of a furnace or AC repair, installing a heat pump is an economical alternative that checks all the boxes.

For some, this means choosing the right heat pump system to provide heat during cooler temperatures, and it might mean choosing the right cooling system to combat soaring outdoor temperatures for others.

Heat Pump vs. Air Conditioner: What Are the Differences?

Homeowners may debate whether to buy a heat pump vs ac. It is important to remember that most HVAC systems on the market today are incredibly efficient. A heat pump provides heating and cooling; it is all you need to maintain comfortable indoor temperatures.

An air conditioner provides only cooling. You can pair an AC system with a heating system, and people often use a furnace to provide heating when they have air conditioning systems.

Do Heat Pumps and Air Conditioners Work in the Same Way?

Heat pumps and air conditioners cool your house in the same way. Both systems use a compressed refrigerant to remove the heat from the home. The hot air goes through a coil in the air handler, which blows it outside.

Heat Pump vs. AC: Which System Is Right for You?

Deciding between a heat pump vs. air conditioner can be difficult. There are several things you should consider.

The budget is always a concern when you upgrade your home. You can invest in a new HVAC system or only need a new air conditioner. Heat pump systems can start at $7000 and go as high as $13000. Air conditioning systems typically start at $5000 and go as high as $10000

A heat pump system will give you peace of mind. Homeowners will be confident that they will be warm and cozy when the outdoor temperature drops and nice and cool during the summer heat.

Homeowners must determine which system will be effective for keeping their house comfortable. You want to ensure that you are choosing a heating and cooling system that is energy efficient.

The design of your house may require many heat pumps, which means more energy to run them. You will need supplemental heat when the outdoor temperatures drop. The size of your home and your climate are important factors to consider.

How Does a Heat Pump Work?

The heat pump is a heating and cooling system’s outdoor unit installed away from the home. During colder months, the heat pump works by pulling heat from the outside air and pumping it into your home.

The heating mode works well in moderate climates. Colder climates may require the addition of electric heat strips to the indoor fan coil for better heat pump efficiency. Homeowners should install a backup heat source in case of a power outage.

The heat pump will pull the hot air from inside your home and transfer it outside during the warmer months. Heat pumps operate with electricity, and they use a reversing valve to reverse the direction of the refrigerant, which determines whether it is in cooling or heating mode.

Pros of a Heat Pump

heat pump vs ac getting best heating and cooling

Heat pumps run on electricity rather than natural gas so that you can reduce greenhouse gas emissions from your house. A sound HVAC system is much more efficient than electric baseboard heaters, and a heat pump is much more effective than a traditional air conditioning unit.

Your heat pump will require very little maintenance. Homeowners should clean the filters regularly, and you should have professionals clean and inspect your heat pump annually to ensure they are in good working order.

Cons of Heat Pump

There are some drawbacks when it comes to heat pumps. Homeowners often pay the cost upfront. Some heat pump installations can be challenging. The life expectancy of heat pumps is unsure, and it will depend on how much the heat pumps work.

Heat pumps work great during mild winters but are less effective when the temperatures drop. Many homes will need both a heat pump and an auxiliary electric heater to maintain warm air, and this additional heat source will require more energy to operate.

What Is Air Conditioning?

An air conditioning system removes the hot air and humidity inside your home. The air conditioner works to return cold air to your house, and the cooling mode transfers the hot air outside.

You can choose an air conditioner that cools one specific room or a central air conditioner that cools the entire house. Central air conditioning systems are more expensive, and they often require the installation of ducts. Central ac has an outdoor unit and an indoor air component that manages the cooling output.

Pros of Air Conditioning

Once you have air conditioning in your home, you likely will not go without it. Cooling systems are essential for good air quality, and air conditioners remove the humidity from the air, which helps with productivity. Most people enjoy a much better night’s sleep when their home is cool and comfortable.

heat pump vs ac using best cooling system

Cons of Air Conditioning

Air conditioners tend to have moisture buildups that can contribute to the growth of mold and fungus, which can be blown into the outside air. It is essential to clean and maintain air conditioners so they don’t contribute to respiratory illness and ailments.

Energy Efficiency and Cost of Operation

The energy efficiency of both heat pumps, the geothermal and air source heat pumps, are far superior to air conditioners. The cost of operating heat pumps and air conditioners is relatively the same when they are in cooling mode. Consumers should look for the energy star symbol when shopping for a heat pump or an air conditioner.

When To Call Pros at Aquarius

The expert technicians at Aquarius can recommend the best heat pump or air conditioner for your house. They will know where to place the heat pump to maximize your heat energy. The technicians can also determine the best place to install central air units to guarantee the coolest results. The pros will help you choose a heat pump vs. an air conditioner.

Chris Thomas
Chris Thomas
1726282284
Our technician for AC check-up, Timothy, was excellent. We had a deficient component that needed replacing (due to standard wear) and he expertly explained the importance of this part and what it does in layman’s terms. He was very personable and friendly- we would have him or any of the Aquarius Home Services staff out for future check-ups and repairs.
Amber Kasprowicz
Amber Kasprowicz
1726253792
Nick was very thorough in his inspection and we appreciated his knowledge and expertise.David, Jon, Matt, Paul and Mao did a fantastic job with our furnace and AC installation. They were efficient, thorough and personable.Ethan did our AC checkup and he was very friendly and knowledgeable. Very happy with all of the services we've gotten.
Lee Place
Lee Place
1726239525
Arrived earlier than estimated time which was awesome. Mike was professional and took his time verifying the issue. Once the issue was resolved verified the rest of the A/C system was working properly as well. Took the time to explain come issues with the system and what I can do as a homeowner to help maintain it.
Tom Holland
Tom Holland
1726239129
Every visit so far with Aquarius has been great. Techs are professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. Highly recommend.
Connie Briol
Connie Briol
1726187495
Technician Tim Halverson was personable and knowledgeable. He clearly explained the process of tuning up my furnace and answered all of my questions completely. I use Aquarius for all of my HVAC, electrical and plumbing needs. Great company!
darkoisg
darkoisg
1726180446
Nick is a very good person to work with, he explains in detail everything he is doing and is very direct in saying what is right and what is wrong.We are very happy that Nick visited our house.THANK YOU.
Tobe Goldberg
Tobe Goldberg
1726148192
We had excellent service from Casey. He was thorough and very conscientious. He stayed until the job was done and explained everything along the way. Highly recommend Aquarius Home Services.
Debbie Mettler
Debbie Mettler
1726106256
Workers were very professional and did extra work to help us out as customers.
Debra Kaye
Debra Kaye
1726104212
David was very thorough, informative, knowledgeable, quick to respond, and kind.I wasn't sure which HVAC company to call but very glad I called Aquarius and that David was our technician.
Kaitlyn Burggraff
Kaitlyn Burggraff
1726081622
Nick was a very excellent technician. Very knowledgeable and thorough with his work. Would recommend to everyone I know!!
Karen Peterson
Karen Peterson
1726072580
Derek D. From Aquarius is the BEST! We trust him 100%!
Sheri Kitzerow
Sheri Kitzerow
1726041919
Brad and his crew arrived at the time stated. Brad explained the what they would be doing for the installation of furnace/heat pump. The work was completed in time frame Brad stated it would take. The workers ran a system test to verify units were installed properly and working. Brad explained/showed me what they did and how the units work. Showed how to use the app on my phone.
CJ FAAS
CJ FAAS
1726015168
Justin was AWESOME!!! He deserves a raise.
Brenda Maguire
Brenda Maguire
1726002377
Very good service
Tammy Roen
Tammy Roen
1725996330
Jenni Evans Black
Jenni Evans Black
1725992859
I appreciate the technicians Aquarius Home Services sent out to check out our A/C and Furnace, Nicholas and Tim! Super kind, knowledgeable, explained things so I could understand and was not pushy about anything!
Leroy Gall
Leroy Gall
1725977145
We needed our outdoor water spigot repaired. Master Plumber, Paul Teale, was very knowledgeable and provided prompt professional service.
Cheryl Voss
Cheryl Voss
1725925582
Debbie Mills
Debbie Mills
1725908431
Excellent customer service! Ethan was thorough and provided a detailed explanation of everything.
Marjorie Rogers
Marjorie Rogers
1725897763
David Kralovec
David Kralovec
1725896602
Nick did a great job diagnosing my existing water system. He clearly explained options and did a great job quickly repairing my system.
John Hable
John Hable
1725894788
Donald Flemino
Donald Flemino
1725668223
Jay Russell
Jay Russell
1725667603
Excellent customer service. Very knowledgeable and personable.Kept us informed. Expert installation as promised. Made sure all was explained and knew how to operate before departing.Highly recommended! Great job!
Sandy Plattner
Sandy Plattner
1725653111
Mike did a great job. Explained everything that he did and what we had to do. We also found out that we were adding salt at the wrong time and what kind of problem that was causing.Give the poor man a raise. He listened to us babble on. Very nice person. You are lucky to have him.
Beth Westrick
Beth Westrick
1725651173
Fast, affordable and professional
JD
JD
1725646876
Ivy Faulkner
Ivy Faulkner
1725640951
Alec was great. He accommodated my limited mobility after surgery and answered all my questions.
Aaron
Aaron
1725640750
Karen Dorn
Karen Dorn
1725637859
Micah was super nice, explained these well, and quick with the fix!
Michele Ryan
Michele Ryan
1725564640
My HVAC full system peak performance check with Marcus M. went great. Marcus was very through and helped explain everything he was doing and made it easy to understand every step of the way. He repaired or cleaned up items found on check relating to my furnace making sure it will be ready for the upcoming season and gave me items to look at in future regarding AC. I would 100% recommend Marcus and would hope to have him come for future maintenance needs.
Marc Akerlind
Marc Akerlind
1725554428
Brandon was excellent. Excellent, timely install, clean, professional, communicative.
Steven Anderson
Steven Anderson
1725493080
Great service very promt and efficient..I would highly recommend my installer and he came back in 6 months to change filters and perform maintenance
Jan leppla
Jan leppla
1725489633
Dave did a fabulous job helping me with installing a ceiling fixture in front hall and purchasing and installing a ceiling light fixture in laundry room. He was very professional, plus being friendly at the same time. Would call to use him in the future!!
Heidi D
Heidi D
1725479693
I've had several interactions with Aquarius this year...HVAC, Plumbing, and Electrical. In all cases, options where thoroughly explained, workmanship was excellent, workers were professional, and no surprises financially. I'd strongly recommend Aquarius for home service needs!
Mark Bennett
Mark Bennett
1725477697
Marcus was very professional, thorough, and knowledgeable. He did and excellent job. I would highly recommend!
david ramsey
david ramsey
1725473352
Lindsay
Lindsay
1725395002
Great service. On time and extremely friendly and detail oriented.
Lori Nelsen
Lori Nelsen
1725390425
B Sirotiak
B Sirotiak
1725200971
Shawn and Casey were very kind and informative. They were happy to show us how stuff worked and were able to present options while laying out pricing in timely manner. We chose to have Aquarius home service continue to maintenance our water treatment system.
Glen Hill
Glen Hill
1725153019
Nick did a great jobThank you
Kraig Peterson
Kraig Peterson
1725051957
Technician was knowledgeable and courteous
Mary Wild
Mary Wild
1724985374
Nick did a GREAT job! He explained what work needed to be performed and then completed it in a timely fashion. We highly recommend Aquarius Home Services!
David Merritt
David Merritt
1724977648
Mark Hamre
Mark Hamre
1724976540
We had the Aquarius technicians install a new furnace, air conditioner and air exchanger. Mick, Chris and the rest of the guys did an outstanding job. They were knowledgeable about HVACs and personable to talk to. They explained how the system works and gave a short tutorial on maintenance. They were hard workers arriving at the expected time. We were very pleased with their work. 5 stars for sure.
dannyboy
dannyboy
1724963859
Expert service, very knowledgeable, courteous and answered all my questions.
×
js_loader
Skip to content